TOWADS A COLLABORATIVE PLURAL LEGALISM IN CAMEROON: MODERN STATE JURISPRUDENCE AND CUSTOMARY LAWS FOR A SOCIAL CONTROL SYSTEM THAT TAKES SOCIOCULTURAL REALITIES INTO ACCOUNT

Authors

  • Ngayi Mvehe Alima

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.61421/IJSSMER.2025.3303

Keywords:

Modern state laws, Customary laws, Social Control, Collaborative Plural legalism

Abstract

For the improvement of legal system and social control mechanisms that reflect social realities, this paper is a discussion about the type of legal pluralism to be put in place through a collaboration of the coexisting modern jurisprudence with customary laws in Cameroon. In other words, the author seeks to examine how Modern State Legal system could interact with Customary laws and Indigenous mechanisms of Social control for Peace and harmony in Cameroon. The research design is explorative, using qualitative method. A questionnaire, Interviews and Life stories were used for Primary data collection; 20 individuals between 35- and 70-Years Old were interviewed, also two Focus Groups Discussion were organized, from each of the four Main Cultural areas of Cameroon. Secondary data come from Documentary Research. Legal Pluralism and Cultural Hybridization Theories have been exploited to understand social facts. According to the results, Law is an element of culture which is dynamic; also as cultural element, Law and mechanisms of social control should be flexible and not static. When the situation in the society change, there should be an opportunity to adjust Laws and mechanisms of social control to the change that has occurred, to fit social realities. The coexistence of traditional laws and mechanisms of Social Control and Modern legal system, can lead to the emergence of a new form of Legal system but the importance lays in the efficiency in maintaining social Order. By using collaborative Legal pluralism, which is appropriate to socio cultural realities in Cameroon; because it is a context where both state and non-state justice exist, but non-state justice mechanisms operate under the umbrella of state authority. Weaknesses of one system can be overcome by the other one’s mechanism. The cultural hybridism can contribute to the trans formation and enrichment of culture. Cultural hybridization also brings challenges as the creation of power relations between cultures that could lead to the disappearance of certain cultures. Therefore, issue of cultural hybridization should be approach by taking into consideration both advantages and disadvantages.  Cameroon is a multiethnic country, if the disadvantages are not taken into account there is a risk of homogenization and cultural assimilation instead of cultural diversity. The result hast also presented the Ghana’s pluralistic legal system as an example of collaborative legal pluralism to be copied in Cameroon. The legal system in Ghana is pluralistic, in that national legal system is based on the mixture of indigenous experiences, religious practices and imported legal experiences from the colonization.  Customary laws and traditions are taken into account in fashioning the jurisprudence.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Author Biography

Ngayi Mvehe Alima

University of Buea, Cameroon

References

Addy, M., 2023, Legal kaleidoscope: Exploring Ghana’s pluralistic legal system, University of Professional Studies, Accra (UPSA), (online).

Adebayo Oba, A.2023, African law and legal pluralism within and beyond national legal system, University of western cape.

Mbuagbo, O.T. and Akoko, R.M, 2004, Motion of Support and Ethno regional politics in Cameroon, Journal of Third World Studies, X X1 n° 1.

Campbell, Meghan and Geoffrey Swenson, 2016, “Legal pluralism and women rights after conflict: The role of CEDAW” Columbia Human Rights Law Review 48 (1)

Enonchon, L. S., 2025, Constitutional Identity, Bijuralism and establishment of Common Law division in the Supreme Court of Cameroon, Legal pluralism and Critical Social Analysis, Routledge, ISSN, (Online).

Enonchong, L.S. and Ashu Eware, 2024, “Conflict transformation through Institutional (re) construction: An examination of common law Division of the Supreme Court of Cameroon.” African conflict and peace building Review14(1):28-54 https//doi.org/10.2979/acp.00002.

Ewing, K. P., 2000, Legislating Religious Freedom: Muslim Challenges to the Relationship between “Church” and “State” in Germany and France. Daedalus 29 Fiaka, 2021

Garland, D.,1996, Social Control. In The Social Science Encyclopedia, Adam Kuper (eds), Routledge: New York.

Jones, Seth G. 2008, “The rise of Afghanistan’s Insurgency: State failure and Jihad”. New York: W.W. Norton in -Swenson, G.,2018, Legal pluralism in theory and practice, International Studies Review, Vol. 20.

Jones, Seth G. 2010, In the Graveyard of Empires: America’s War. New York: Norton.

Kantor, P., 1996, Domestic violence against Women. A global issue, in Nanda Serena, Cultural Anthropology, (2004).

Kuipers, Joel., C. ,1990, Power in performance: The Creation of textural Authority in Weywa Ritual Speech. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.

Miller, B., 2006, Social order and social conflict in Cultural Anthropology (4th ed.), George Washington University.

Minkano, E. K., 2021, Advocacy for Customary Justice Reform in Cameroon: What is to be done with Customary Law? A Journal of Contemporary Research, www. Universalacademicservices. Org.

Miyazawa, S., 1992, Policing in Japan/ A study on making Crime, in Frank, G. Bennett, Jr. and al. Albany: State University of New York Press.

Nanda, S. 1994. Political Systems and Social Control in Cultural Anthropology, Wadsworth Publishing Company, Belmont, California.

Peters, E. and Ubink, J.M. 2015, “Restorative and Flexible Customary Procedures and their Gendered Impact: A preliminary view on Namibia’s Formalization of Traditional Court; 3 The Journal of Legal Pluralism, Unofficial law 47 (2).

Rowe, W. and Shelling, V., 1991, Memory and Modernity. Popular culture in Latina; Amazon

Swenson, G.,2018, Legal pluralism in theory and practice, International Studies Review, Vol. 20.

Tamanaha, B., 2007, Understanding legal pluralism: past to present, local to global, University of Sydney, vol. 30.

Time, Victoria, 2000, Legal pluralism and harmonization of law: An examination of thye process of reception and adoption of both civil and common law in Cameroo criminal justice 24(1):19-29 https //doi.org.10.1080/24036.2000.9678650.

Tuncer, F. F., 2023, Discussing globalization and cultural hybridization, Universal Journal of History and culture, Online.

Yanou, A. M. 2009, The local Courts, decentralization and Good Governance / The Case of the English Speaking provinces of Cameroon, Online.

Downloads

Published

2025-05-20

How to Cite

Ngayi Mvehe Alima. (2025). TOWADS A COLLABORATIVE PLURAL LEGALISM IN CAMEROON: MODERN STATE JURISPRUDENCE AND CUSTOMARY LAWS FOR A SOCIAL CONTROL SYSTEM THAT TAKES SOCIOCULTURAL REALITIES INTO ACCOUNT. International Journal of Social Science, Management and Economics Research, 3(3), 31–52. https://doi.org/10.61421/IJSSMER.2025.3303